Wednesday, May 27, 2026

AEW Double or Nothing 2026

AEW Double or Nothing 2026
Queens, New York - May 2026


CHAMPIONSHIP RUNDOWN: Coming into this show, the AEW World Heavyweight Champion was Darby Allin, the AEW Women's World Champion was Thekla, the World Tag Team Champions were FTR, the TNT Champion was Kevin Knight, the TBS Championship was vacant at the time of the show, Kazuchika Okada was the International Champion, the World Trios Championship was held by The Conglomeration (Roderick Strong, Orange Cassidy, and Kyle O'Reilly), Jon Moxley was the Continental Champion, Lena Kross and Megan Bayne were the Women's Tag Team Champions, and Mark Davis held the AEW National Championship. 



Adam Copeland and Christian challenged FTR in an I Quit match for the AEW World Tag Team Championships to start the show. The Queens crowd was molten hot from the jump as the two teams went at it each other, brawling in and out of the ring. A "We Want Tables" chant started up at minute 2 but got silenced when Dax wrapped his arm in barbwire. Christian took hold of some and wrapped it around the middle rope before tripping Dax into it with a front leg sweep. Copeland went to work with a belt, whipping both members of FTR to the crowd's delight. Moments later, Christian got sent into the ring post shoulder-first and then hit with a chair as Copeland grabbed hold of a ladder. Suplex onto the ladder by Copeland onto Dax! Copeland brought a table out to another big pop and looked to put Wheeler through it but Dax broke things up. Copeland clotheslined Dax out of the ring and went over himself, putting himself in harm's way as Wheeler grabbed a chair. After hitting him in the back with it, Wheeler put it around Copeland's neck and ran him into the post. Dax grabbed a toolbox from ringside and brought it into the ring but Christian caught him with a lowblow. Christian grabbed pliers and yanked on Dax's nose and then Wheeler's crotch! Dax saved his partner by slamming the box into Christian's head and then delivered some wicked chairshots to Christian's injured arm. Copeland took the next big bump, a spike pile-driver on the announce table (which didn't break). Considering Copeland had to take close to a decade off due to a neck injury, it was a pretty crazy move. FTR tried to crush Christian's wrist with a cinder block but it broke apart on the steps so they simply put it on top of Christian's wrist and then smashed it repeatedly with a chair. Christian still wouldn't quit, making a lewd comment about FTR's mother when the mic was placed in front of him instead, and the crowd erupted into a chant of "Oh, Christian's Your Father" to the tune of "Seven Nation Army." Once again, the ref asked Christian if he wanted to quit - to which Christian responded "Go fuck yourself." Great. FTR couldn't get a spike pile-driver to go and Christian took out both guys, sending Dax into the corner and hitting Wheeler with an Unprettier. Stokely took off the top turnbuckle and gave it to Dax, but Christian caught him with a spear! Christian tried to choke him out with the rope but Wheeler broke it up and then choked Christian out with the barbwire. Shatter Machine! Christian rolled to the outside and then back into the ring, barely selling it. Copeland took out both members of FTR with spears and I'm guessing the awkwardness of that sequence was based on some sort of positioning mistake. Copeland grabbed a chair and Dax begged off but Stokely nailed him with a cheap shot and Copeland got hit with the Shatter Machine! But here comes Beth Phoenix! Stokely went running towards her and got leveled for it, kicked into the steel steps - but then Dax caught her and whipped her into them too! Dax went to set the table on fire, spraying it down with lighter fluid. They positioned Beth Pheonix on the ring apron, with Stokely holding her in place, but Wheeler (predictably) ended up spearing Stokely through it instead. Back in the ring, Dax set Copeland up for a Con-Chair-To but Copeland wouldn't quit and Pheonix saved him with a low blow (followed by a mule kick to the groin by Christian). Copeland hit a pile driver and Christian applied a Sharpshooter but Dax still wouldn't quit so Copeland locked in a crossface too! Pheonix then busted out "spike," the huge club with spikes on it. Copeland rubbed it into Dax's head, finally forcing him to say I Quit. Very solid crowd-pleasing opener that played to Christian and Copeland's strengths in 2026. (3/5)

Konosuke Takeshita vs. Kazuchika Okada followed with Okada's AEW International Championship on the line. This match had been building for months. Takeshita came in with more babyface support despite this technically being a heel/heel match as both men were members of the Don Callis Family. A "holy shit" chant started before they even locked up. As expected, we got some nifty sequences featuring multiple counters and signature moves, but Okada's heelishness was what stitched everything together. Highlights included Okada nailing a Rainmaker on the apron that sent Takeshita to the floor, an awesome running boot in the corner by Takeshita that was captured beautifully by the camera man, Takeshita countering a Rainmaker into a Blue Thunder Bomb, and some of the best nearfalls I've seen recently due to Okada's expert timing. At one point, Callis prevented Okada from piledriving Takeshita on the floor, which made sense storytelling-wise but still seemed out of character. Okada eventually hit his patented dropkick and attempted a Rainmaker but Takeshita hit one of his own! Okada hit another dropkick but Takeshita hit the Power Drive Knee - but Okada kicked out at 1! Wow. Takeshita hit Okada with another brutal forearm and then hit a Raging Fire to end the match and get the clean win. Very good match. (3.5/5)

After the match, it seemed like the rest of the Don Callis Family was going to possibly turn on Takeshita, but out came Kyle Fletcher, making his return to AEW! Fletcher stared Takeshita down and then got in Okada's face too. Takeshita and Fletcher gave each other a big hug, Fletcher handed Takeshita the title, and then walloped him with a big clothesline. This was really well done and got great heat. Takeshita/Fletcher should be bonkers good. When Fletcher went to lift up the belt, he and Okada both grabbed hold at the same time, which was another really cool twist. 

Athena took on Mina Shirakawa in a first round match of the Owen Hart Foundation Women's Tournament next. There was a bit of telegraphing early, but Athena's offense looked terrific and vicious and the crowd woke up as the match wore on (and got smoother). Highlights included Athena's fireman's carry slam, Mina's barrel roll splash to the floor, Mina spiking Athena's head into the mat from a hurricanrana, and Athena delivering a brilliant surfboard-curb stomp move. The closing stretch featured some excellent struggle and a clean finish after Athena hit her finishing move. Another great Athena performance and, without looking into it too deeply, one of Shirakawa's best matches (on the AEW roster at least). (3/5)

The AEW Continental Championship was on the line as Jon Moxley defended the strap against Kyle O'Reilly in the next match. The story here was that O'Reilly had Moxley's number in every one of their previous matches (though I'm not 100% if that's "all-time" or just over the past couple years in AEW). Jim Ross joined the commentary desk for this one, which had the added stipulation of having no time limit (as O'Reilly had gone 20 minutes in an Eliminator match a couple weeks earlier). We got a bit of grappling early on, but most of the limb work was abandoned when they started laying in their strikes. The action went to the floor and O'Reilly hit a running knee off the apron and then some kicks to the chest and back of the leg. Moxley dodged one and O'Reilly's shin went right into the post, changing the momentum of the match considerably. Moxley went to work on the knee from there, but O'Reilly showed tremendous grit, using every opening he could find to nail Mox with one of his signature knee strikes. O'Reilly managed to lock in a Fujiwara armbar but Mox countered it into a half-crab and then a leg lock. Mox went for a Dragon Screw but O'Reilly transitioned it into an armbar and then an ankle lock! Mox refused to tap, biting his fist in pain, forcing O'Reilly to release the hold in order to inflict more damage. Mox went to the outside to regroup and got curb stomped on his way back into the ring, but then hit a cutter to even things up. I didn't love the no-sell on the Stomp there, though Excalibur tried to explain it away as O'Reilly's knee damage causing him to not "get all of it." Both guys were back on their feet for another exchange that ended in a double-down off of some lariats. On their knees, O'Reilly and Mox traded stiff punches and jabs and then got to their feet to do some more sparring. Mox hit a Death Rider and applied a sleeper, but O'Reilly countered it into an ankle lock once more! Mox brought O'Reilly down and applied one of his own, but O'Reilly went for a pin and got 2. Mox kept hold of O'Reilly's ankle and O'Reilly simply couldn't make it to the ropes and was forced to tap. A very solid match with a nice clean ending. The post-match handshake was a cool moment too, another example of how Moxley has morphed into a bit of a Babyface despite not really changing all that much since the days when the Blackpool Combat Club were the most evil and violent of heels. (3/5)

Will Ospreay vs. Samoa Joe in a Round 1 match from the Men's Owen Hart Foundation Tournament was next. As soon as Joe got in the ring, Ospreay hit him with a springboard cutter, showing incredible urgency. Joe cut him off but Ospreay kept the pressure on, hitting a 450 splash for 2 and then immediately going into an armbar (that got broken up when Joe grabbed the bottom rope). Ospreay went for another big dive to the floor, landed on his feet, and got caught in a choke and then sent into the barricade with ridiculous force. Joe took over back in the ring with his some of his signature striking looking as good as ever. I also really dug Ospreay's selling at this point, making everything look devastating (which isn't hard to do considering how stiff some of the kicks and chops were). Ospreay managed to deliver a double stomp to Joe's left arm, followed it up with a dropkick, applied an armbreaker, hit some chops, and then delivered one of his trademark handspring heel kicks. Ospreay hit some Kawada Kicks, a big kick to the head, but then missed the Oscutter when Joe walked away (to a huge pop). Joe hit the powerbomb-into-the-Boston Crab and then transitioned it into an STF but Ospreay wouldn't tap so Joe turned it into a crossface. I've always loved Joe's submission transitions. Ospreay got his foot on the rope to break things up but then ate a few Hashimoto-style kicks to the chest, powering through to get to his feet. Joe nailed him with open hand shots and then a spinning elbow strike to once again cut him off. Joe went for some sort of suplex or slam but Ospreay countered it into a Styles Clash! Hidden Blade! 1...2...shoulder up at 2.5 (though the ref's pause was noticeable). He went for another Hidden Blade but Joe caught him with a snap powerslam! Ospreay grabbed hold of an arm but Joe used his size to turn it into a pin and then a Coquina Clutch. Ospreay pinned his shoulders, forcing Joe to release the hold...Sidewalk Slam by Joe! Another clutch! Ospreay was on the brink of getting choked out but grabbed the bottom rope on the third arm drop! Joe hoisted Ospreay to the top rope, hit him with some headbutts and attempted a Muscle Buster but Ospreay escaped! Hidden Blade! 1 Count! Another Hidden Blade to the back of the head! That one got him! Wow. Incredible match that didn't overstay its welcome, followed a story that made sense and didn't require any no-selling or "superhero"/"video game" style sequences, and yet another incredible performance from Samoa Joe. Really, really great. (4/5)

Swerve Strickland made his return after a somewhat lengthy in-ring hiatus in the next match, taking on Bandido in another Owen Hart Tournament match-up. Despite being the heel, Swerve had plenty of support from the crowd, though Bandido won many fans over with his impressive shows of agility. Highlights included Swerve's impressive work on the back of Bandido's neck, Bandido delivering a senton off the apron onto Swerve (who was sitting on a chair on the floor), Bandido hitting a reverse hurricanrana from the apron to the floor that was insane, and an even more unbelievable spot in which Swerve jumped onto Bandido's shoulders for a House Call before hitting a Swerve Stomp for 2.5. Bandido's early momentum got cut off when he missed a diving headbutt in the corner and ate the middle buckle with Swerve following it up with a release German suplex into the corner for extra damage. This is where Swerve really leaned into his most heelish tendencies - slowing the pace, targeting the neck, really punishing Bandido without doing anything too flashy or babyface-ish. AEW gets a bad rap for having matches with too little selling or are fought at too fast of a pace, but everything mattered in this match and they built up to the big moments well, giving things room to breathe when they needed to. Bandido attempted (and connected) with his 21 Plex finish but, when he tried to hold the bridge for the pin, his neck couldn't sustain it. We got another incredible sequence resulting in another 21 Plex attempt but Swerve countered it into a Swervedriver! Wow. House Call! Another great, great match. (4/5)

Thekla defended the AEW Women's World Championship against Hikaru Shida, Jamie Hayter, and Kris Statlander in the next match. The three challengers went for the champion to start before going after each other. Stat and Hayter had a fun exchange soon before we got some rapid nearfalls. Thekla hit a bunch of sharp running boots throughout the match and a big crossbody from the top to the floor, a spot I usually loathe but actually looked good here. Thekla applied a nasty submission capped off by prying Stat's jaw open but got her hand bit to break it up and then took some big slams. Thekla went for a tarantula but Stat countered it by flipping her face-first into the corner. Up to the top they went where Thekla hit a superplex but got attacked by Shida when she celebrated a bit too long. Shida and Hayter took over in the corner and Shida hit a superplex of her own before Hayter caught her with a spinning belly-to-back. This led to another dizzying array of suplexed and nearfalls that led to all four women selling on the mat. A fourway strike exchange erupted before Stat and Hayter went back at it, trading forearms and hitting each other with big crossbodies. Tilt-a-whirl backbreaker by Shida on Thekla! Falcon Arrow by Shida, but Thekla countered it into another pin attempt! Roundhouse kick by Thekla and then the Bray Wyatt-esque creepy back bridge - but Stat grabbed hold of her and brought her up for the Sunday Night Fever. Thekla escapes and sent her into Hayter, who nailed her with an Exploder! Big boot by Hayter on Thekla! Stat got back up but got whipped into a jumping knee by Shida! Hayter with a backbreaker on Thekla and went for the lariat but Thekla got free and applied the Octopus Stretch submission! Hayter powered out and dropped her with a backbreaker and then nailed her with the Hayterade lariat! 1...2...Shida breaks it up! Shida with another Falcon Arrow and then an awkward submission but Statlander broke it up. Shida slapped Stat in the face so Stat went after her, booting her out of the ring and then sending her into the steps. Statlander with a pump kick on the floor to Hayter! Thekla went for the Spear but Stat jumped over her and hits the Sunday Night Fever! Shida broke it up, though, with a kendo stick to the back! As it is a 4-way match, this was not a disqualification. Hayter took Shida out on the outside as Thekla nailed a stomp in the middle of the ring to get the W. Wow. This was all-killer, no filler. Everyone looked great here. (4/5)

The Stadium Stampede was next with Jericho, Lashley, Shelton Benjamin, Kenny Omega, Jack Perry, and The Young Bucks (yes, that's SEVEN participants) taking on Ricochet, The Gates of Agony, Mark Davis, Andrade El Idolo, and The Dogs. Before the fight began, we got a short video of the heels arriving in various cars, including a monster truck. The babyfaces also got a neat pre-match video, set to the Metallica deep cut "Devil's Dance," that featured a brief clip of MVP and Jericho shaking hands, a not-so-subtle nod to a reported beef they had several years ago (before MVP joined AEW). The crowd was absolutely amped for this from the jump, singing along to "Judas" and then chanting "We Hurt People" before the bell sounded. As one would expect, this was a wild brawl with wrestlers duking it out everywhere and the cameras unable to capture all of it at the same time. This was not a match for fans of psychology and long-term selling or anything other than fun callbacks and "moments" - Lashley choke slamming Ricochet out of the ring, Andrade delivering Tres Amigo suplexes, a silly cameo from Lio Rush when the fight went to the medical area backstage, Toa Leona hoisting up both Bucks and Jack Perry for a fireman's carry slam, Ricochet hitting a shooting star press onto 8-9 guys, including some of his own teammates, the Bucks super-kicking Clark Connors onto an escalator, a super goofy abdominal stretch leverage spot, the Elite delivering a trio of suicide dives followed by Shelton Benjamin's trademark over-the-top rope one, Andrade taking a breather to get a selfie with a young lady (who ended up switching places with a wig-wearing Luchasaurus!), a 5-in-a-row hurricanrana spot, Jericho dumping out a huge bag of tennis balls (a nod to the arena being the home of the Billie Jean King Tennis Center) and suplexing Ricochet onto them, etc. etc. I even liked the use of Satnam Singh! This match delivered non-stop fun for well over 30 minutes. The MVP of the match may have been Toa Leona - mostly because I don't think anyone would've predicted that he would be involved so many of the best moments in a match that featured as many stars as this one did. Mark Davis, sporting a bandage wrapped around his head, ended up (theoretically?) crushed by the Jurassic Express schoolbus but somehow survived and ended up at ringside to eat some nasty suplexes on the floor and get put through a table. The closing minutes saw the babyfaces all hit huge moves, including a One Winged Angel through a table onto Andrade. It looked like Ricochet would eat the pinfall, but it ended up being Bishop Kaun in an unexpected twist after Kaun shoved Rico out of the way before Jericho could hit him with the spinning back elbow. A blast of a match. (4/5)

The main event followed - MJF challenging Darby Allin for the AEW Championship in a Title vs. Hair Match. Darby took an absolutely nasty head drop within the first 3 minutes that set the tone for the rest of the match. I'm not sure if it was planned for him to take the bump the way he did, but it absolutely worked at setting up the rest of MJF's attack and the eventual finish. As one would expect, Darby withstood a ton of punishment, both when he connected and when he missed multiple Coffin Breaks. There was heavy use of headlock takedowns and a terrific rolling pin sequence. Some of the highlights included MJF hitting a package piledriver on the overturned steps and Darby coming off the scaffolding by the entranceway with a Coffin Drop through a table. To their credit, the big spots were allowed to breathe and because they often incapacitated both men, it made sense that the subsequent pinfalls - occuring sometimes a full minute or two after the impact of the move - were unsuccessful. When MJF finally did string together enough offense, after Allin's body "gave out on him" mid-Scorpion Death Lock due to blood loss from a gash on the back of his skull, the match wrapped up decisively. Extra kudos to MJF for turning a crowd that, theoretically, could've been 50/50 or even pro-MJF and doing enough heelish shtick to get booed in front of what was essentially his hometown. On any other show, this might be your Match of the Night, but this show was so stacked that this just was another excellent match. (4/5)

Oh, and after the match, Kevin Knight turned heel by attacking Darby Allin. They've been quietly teasing a heel turn for Knight, but I'm not sure I'm fully in favor of it so soon after Swerve Strickland also had a fairly dramatic heel turn that didn't necessarily lead to anything (though there is obviously still plenty of time to build towards a rematch with Omega and it also makes some sense that they'd want a match of that caliber to potentially headline one of the major PPVs between now and All In). 


With a Kwang Score of 3.61, Double or Nothing 2026 was a show so consistently strong that it may go down as the greatest wrestling PPV of all time. When the "worst" match on a show is as fun as the opener, features work as good as what Athena did in the Shirakawa match, or is as solid and physical as the Continental Championship match, you are watching a special show. Remarkably, AEW achieved this without having to rely on any overt gore, keeping the "color" to a minimum and really making sure every big moment "popped" and felt organic in the context of the matches and storylines. Looking at my own database, I only have a handful of shows rated higher overall - specifically Money in the Bank 2023, WrestleMania XXXI, and Bash at the Beach 94'

FINAL RATING - Curt Hennig Level

Saturday, May 23, 2026

TNA Genesis 2012

TNA Genesis 2012
Orlando, FL - January 2012

CHAMPIONSHIP RUNDOWN: Coming into this show, the TNA World Champion was Bobby Roode, Austin Aries was the X-Division Champion, the Television Champion was Robbie E, the Knockouts Champion was Gail Kim, and the Knockouts Tag Team Champions were Gail Kim and Madison Rayne.


The show kicked off with Austin Aries defending his X-Division Championship in a 4-way elimination match against Jesse Sorensen, Zema Ion (who, at one time, went by DJZ for a spell and now goes by Joaquin Wilde in the WWE), and Kid Kash. Solid X-Divison match here that benefitted from the mix of styles and characters and experience levels too. Liked the interconnectivity of some of the spots and sequences. Zema's 450 didn't look perfect but was still impressive. Nothing super special here but a good match. (3/5)

Devon took on "The Pope" D'Angelo Dinero in the next match. I wasn't expecting much out of this contest as I'm not a big fan of either guy and this storyline - with Devon's sons betraying their father by becoming part of Dinero's entourage - had been running for quite awhile by this point without delivering anything good. I was pleasantly surprised by this, though, as they stuck to a simple story and didn't get too cutesy with it as Dinero, the heel, ended up slapping around Devon's sons when they wouldn't attack their dad. I'm not sure if Vince Russo booked this or not, but if he did, kudos for the restraint in not "overbooking" this! I think Devon should've gotten the W a big quicker after his fire-up, but that's just a slight criticism of a match that exceeded my expectations by sticking with a straightforward approach and letting the emotion of the match carry things. (2.5/5)

Gunner vs. Rob Van Dam followed. Gunner is managed by Ric Flair, who looks like he fully recognizes how lame and unimportant this pairing is. Gunner, like Crimson before him, in the midst of a push that seems completely unwarranted considering how unexciting he is. Not much chemistry with Van Dam, but RVD's TNA run was mostly lackluster so I wasn't expecting much out of him. The match goes about 7 minutes and ends with Gunner DDTing Van Dam on the concrete floor. RVD should sell it like death but doesn't. Not very good, but inoffensive. (1.5/5)

Mickie James challenged Gail Kim for the Knockouts Championship in the next match, with Gail Kim's tag partner, Madison Rayne, hanging from a Shark Cage (per the decision of TNA Knockouts Division General Manager wanna-be, Velvet Skye). James and Kim worked hard, but there was definitely some "slop" to this, including James' attempt a hurricanrana on the outside. I was expecting some sort of swerve with Skye turning on James, but am glad that didn't happen. However, the finish was really, really flat with James getting DQ'd when the ref caught her using brass knucks. The crowd immediately chanted "Bullshit," which was well-deserved as it felt like the match was only just getting started when it ended at well under 10 minutes. (1.5/5)

Abyss took on Bully Ray in a Monster's Ball match next with the added stipulation that if Abyss lost, he would be forced to rejoin Immortal. I'll credit for Bully Ray to trying to give this match more story and structure than your typical "kitchen sink hardcore" match, but when you make the audience wait for the big spots, they need to be memorable and impressive and not many of them were. Abyss got cut up on his arm from barbwire and Bully took a chokeslam into the tacks to finish this, but because of his ring gear, it didn't seem particularly vicious or painful. Ray was a great heel at this point in his career and his chickenshit antics helped his matches "pop," but he was never a superworker and one can only carry the plodding, one-note Abyss so far. (2.5/5)

Samoa Joe and Magnus teamed up to take on the reigning TNA World Tag Team Champions, Crimson and Matt Morgan in the next match. Joe and Magnus had decent chemistry for a "thrown together" tag team, but this was still not very good. At under 10 minutes, this wasn't much of a title match and there wasn't much of a story to it. Part of the problem is that all 4 guys were essentially "tweeners" as Crimson wasn't particularly popular or over, Joe had been turned and re-turned multiple times and no longer had a main event aura, and Magnus and Morgan, while technically faces (?) were not without their vocal detractors in the Impact Zone. Heatless and not interesting enough to carry it over the hump, this was inoffensive but below average. (2/5)

Next up - Kurt Angle vs. James Storm. This is the kind of match that really hurts Kurt Angle's reputation for me as the crowd wants to care about this, but the match is just boring. Angle eventually wins with a low blow, going back on his promise to win the match by "out wrestling" the "barroom brawler." Didn't Christopher Daniels do this same sort of gimmick a few months earlier? Also, it would've worked better if Angle had really upped the cockiness and arrogance throughout the match, getting the over-the-top heel heat that this match desperately needed to work. Storm is alright, but nothing more. Someone on Cagematch described this match as "flat" and that feels like the best descriptor for it. (2/5)

Main event time - Jeff Hardy vs. Bobby Roode for the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. The build-up for this match was all about Hardy's redemption story after his embarrassing "performance" at Victory Road 2011. I was pleasantly surprised at how much better this match was then some of the other Bobby Roode title defenses from this run. Hardy is wrestling with a ton of energy and, against a very charismatic (and very over) performer who the fans believe might actually get the W, Roode's methodical pacing - around this time he was getting compared to Triple H quite a bit - does work at building suspense and drama. Unfortunately, the finish was incredibly deflating and makes this impossible to recommend as Roode - spoiler alert - attacks the referee in order to retain the title. Its the same sort of non-finish that we got at the previous PPV (where an Ironman match ended in a draw) and, while it does get Roode some heat, I can't imagine anyone who spent money on this show wanting to spend money on the next event. Points awarded for the first 16 or so minutes of this match, too bad they couldn't find a better way to end it. (2/5)


With a Kwang Score of 2.13-out-of-5, Genesis 2012 is a mostly rough watch with only one match that can be considered above-average (the spirited opener) and two matches that are average-at-best but exceed expectations only because they're better than one would expect given the participants (Abyss vs. Bully Ray and Devon vs. D'Angelo Dinero). The main event isn't too bad until the finish renders the previous 15 minutes meaningless and the Mickie James/Gail Kim is also a disappointment.

FINAL RATING - DUDleyville

TNA Against All Odds 2012

TNA Against All Odds 2012
Orlando, FL - February 2012

CHAMPIONSHIP RUNDOWN: Coming into the match, the TNA World Champion was Bobby Roode, the X-Division Champion was Austin Aries, the TNA World Tag Team Champions were Crimson and Matt Morgan, Gail Kim was the TNA Knockouts Champion (and also one half of the Knockouts Tag Team Champions with Madison Rayne), and Robbie E. held the Television Champion.



After a music video hyping the show and featuring the company's top stars, including Hulk Hogan, the show kicked off with a Number One Contender's match for the X-Division Championship held by Austin Aries - Zema Ion vs. Jesse Sorensen. I'm not going to give this match a rating because it ends before it even gets started as Ion comes off the apron with a moonsault, his knees knock into the top of Sorensen's head, and Sorensen goes down to the arena floor and never gets up. Ion gloats in the ring, the ref gets close to counting him out, Ion breaks the count (trying to buy time for Sorensen), and then the ref checks on him and Sorensen is clearly injured. The neck injury would end up costing Sorensen his career, though he did remain employed by TNA for over a year. 

Trying to fill time (I assume), they go to the back and Bobby Roode cuts a promo. While I've been unimpressed with Roode's matches on these past few shows, his promo is pretty good. We then go back to the ring for Robbie E's Television Championship Invitational. Shannon Moore takes up the challenge and they deliver a solid-if-unremarkable 10-minute match. Moore was a skilled high flier and a solid hand, but his gimmick never clicked or felt "real." This is one of the better Robbie E matches I've seen, though that's still not saying much and I must admit to probably having seen fewer than 8 in my life. Robbie E eventually gets the win due to interference from his bodyguard, "Robbie T" (aka Big Rob Terry). (2.5/5)

The Knockouts Championship is on the line in the next match as Gail Kim defends against Tara. I was optimistic about this match, but this is not good. Most of the drama of the match involves Kim arguing with Madison Rayne, her tag team partner, but their split doesn't really play into the match at all as Kim wins clean in under 7 minutes. Tara does a good job selling knee damage, but losing so quickly in what was played-up as a major title opportunity/defense hurts her credibility considerably. I'm not sure what the TNA producers were thinking in not giving Kim and Tara a bit more time as I'd assume Ion/Sorensen was meant to last longer than 4 minutes. Very underwhelming, forgettable, meaningless match. (1/5)

The TNA Tag Team Champions, Matt Morgan and Crimson, defended their titles against Magnus and Samoa Joe in a rematch from the previous TNA PPV. I really love Samoa Joe but this is the stretch that prevents him from being a top 10-20 candidate for me in the GOAT conversation as he shows so little fire or enthusiasm in these matches. I get that him and Magnus are ostensibly supposed to be heels - though, they do nothing heelish in the match - so his calculated, cold demeanor is maybe purposeful, but as the only guy in the ring who the fans have ever connected with, its kind of up to him to draw them in and make things exciting and interesting. Simply put, a true great will drag a bunch of C- wrestlers to a B match and that's just not the case here (or for much of Joe's matches from these "lost years"). The finish is unconvincing and Crimson is protected for reasons I can't comprehend as Crimson finally getting pinned or submitted was the only dramatic element they had to work with. (1/5)

Alex Shelley challenged Austin Aries in the next match for his X-Division Championship. They got 15 minutes and they worked hard, but this match never clicked with me beyond just being in the average/good range. Shelley and Austin are both smart workers who imbue their work with sound psychology and strategy and I liked the long-form storytelling as we got a bit of mirror work down the stretch and some nice callbacks. That being said, there was an "exhibition" feel to the match that I didn't particularly like with the result never being in question. This match checks a lot of boxes that great matches need checked, but it somehow isn't a great match itself. (3/5)

AJ Styles took on Frankie Kazarian in the next contest. The story coming into this was that Kazarian and Styles, who had been partnered up in the Wildcard Tag Tournament that took place several weeks (months?) earlier, had hit a rough patch because of the influence of Christopher Daniels, who was holding something over Kazarian's head (it had not been revealed yet what that was). Because of the story, Styles is wrestling to beat some sense into Kazarian, while Kazarian is wrestling to just get through the match (and hopefully get a win) without injuring or disrespecting his friend. Kazarian gets over the fact that he's conflicted and deserves some credit for his performance, but melodrama is still a tough sell in pro-wrestling and the crowd seems completely disinterested. At nearly 20 minutes, this was a chore to get through, which is shocking because AJ has pulled better matches out of much less talented opponents. (1.5/5)

Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff pull a Siegfried and Roy here as they magically take a 12-minute match and make it feel like 20+. The story here is that Garrett Bischoff had moved on from being a referee to becoming a wrestler and had been feuding with his old man after Garrett called for the bell in Hogan's "retirement" match against Sting (Hogan would actually wrestle 2 more non-televised matches in 2012) at Bound for Glory a few months prior. Eric Bischoff had remained a heel and was now partnering with the super generic Gunner, who piledrove Garrett on the arena floor, putting him out of action for awhile. After rehabbing the injury, Garrett got together with a new trainer - Hogan - to help him prepare for the grudge match we get on this show, which isn't terrible, but isn't interesting or exciting at all. Neither guy in the ring has a single ounce of charisma or personality and Eric Bischoff's over-the-top heel shtick was the laziest choice they could've gone with for a storyline that actually had some potential. I hate to fantasy book a no-win storyline like this (at the end of the day, Garrett Bischoff wasn't TV ready and Gunner was just flat-out boring, the wrestling equivalent of burnt, dry toast) but instead of Eazy E playing the over-the-top jerk, his motivation for trying to stop his son from getting into the ring should've been that he knew the dangers and that he was "protecting him" and that, when Garrett refused, he was forced to hire Gunner to put an end to Garrett's dream (a motivation that comes across, sarcastically, in Bischoff's pre-match promo but would've been far more realistic than Eric Bischoff actually trying to maim his own child). Anyway, the match goes 12 minutes but is so uneventful and boring that it very much feels like two guys walking through a scripted "rehearsal" of the "easiest" match possible so that they don't embarrass themselves with any actual high spots. Total dreck but I'll give it a half-point for effort. (0.5/5)

Main event time - Bobby Roode defending the TNA World Heavyweight Championship against Bully Ray, James Storm, and Jeff Hardy with Sting serving as the Special Enforcer. This wasn't terrible or anything, but felt like a "B-show" main event. Bully Ray's heel act was more over than Roode's. Jeff Hardy was more over as a babyface than Storm was. I would've liked to see more teasing of an upset victory for Storm or Bully Ray. The story began with Roode trying to get Bully on his side but Bully waiting outside the ring for his moment to strike, leaving the champion to have to deal with Hardy and Storm. As the match wore on, any brief alliances were cast aside. We got some ref bumps and eventually Sting came into the match and was essentially forced to count the pin for Roode after he inadvertently hit Hardy with the title (Roode ducked). They really milked Sting's inner turmoil, which made the fact that Bully Ray and Storm didn't break up the pinfall extra noticeable. Average match. (2.5/5)


Against all odds, TNA managed to put on an even less-recommendable PPV from the previous one I reviewed, Genesis 2012. The main event is an improvement but the rest of the card is a rough viewing with AJ vs. Kazarian being underwhelming, Garrett Bischoff vs. Gunner being the exact level of "not good" one would expect, and Gail Kim vs. Tara being another example of how overrated this era of the Knockouts Division was in hindsight. For the second show in a row, the best match featured Austin Aries, but its hard to get too enthusiastic about watching Aries in 2026. With a Kwang Score of just 1.71-out-of-5, this is the lowest rated TNA show I've reviewed since Sacrifice 2011 and the second-lowest rated TNA show I've ever reviewed.

FINAL RATING - DUDleyville


Random Matches

Kendall Windham, Stan Hansen, and Ted DiBiase vs. Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, and Yoshinari Ogawa (09/29/1993, AJPW): More than anything, this match is all about the awesomeness of Stan Hansen and, to a lesser extent, Toshiaki Kawada. Ogawa is here to take the beating and he's (unsurprisingly) great in that role, taking some serious punishment from Hansen (including a powerbomb to finish him off). The match only goes a little over 10 minutes, not long enough to ever really move beyond just being "good." I was very surprised by how young DiBiase looked as you could've fooled me if you said this match was from 83' and not 93'. Sadly, I'm not saying that because DiBiase puts on a particularly memorable or spirited performance, but he still looks pretty good here considering he'd be essentially retired as an in-ring performer by the end of the year. (2.5/5)


Aja Kong vs. KAORU (02/13/2000, GAEA): I haven't seen much from the GAEA promotion and I must admit that while I've gone pretty far deep into the rabbit hole of great joshi wrestling, I've watched mostly 80s and mid-90s stuff. Anyway...this is a crazy violent match and I wasn't at all surprised to see that it had a super-high 9.57 score on Cagematch. Its the kind of match that showcases the brilliance of Aja Kong (which I already knew) and makes me want to see a bunch more from KAORU. There's some really unique use of weapons in this match, lots of great little moments, and I loved KAORU's plan of attack and how, once she realized Kong's arm/hand was seriously injured, she went right after it mercilessly. At only 16 minutes, the match isn't as epic as other highly-praised joshi matches, but I don't mind the comparative brevity because there is never a dull moment and everything they do is purposeful and advances the drama. Another absolute gem of a match out of Kong, who is maybe one of the best "big man" wrestlers just because she is able to get across both dominance and vulnerability better than almost any "giant" I've ever seen. (4/5)


Roddy Piper vs. Buddy Rose (05/19/1979, PNW): This one is a Lumberjack match, though they don't really spend all that much time outside of the ring and the lumberjacks don't come into play until the end. The action is okay if you're into this style, which is very minimal and brawl-based. The crowd is into this because both guys were mega-over with the Portland crowd but this is not a match that will blow you away aside from the heat. Fun for what it is and never boring, sure, but this will really only interest and impress those that like "old school 'rasslin'." (2.5/5)


Toshiaki Kawada and Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Skywalker Nitron and Butch Masters (11/20/1990, AJPW): If you're reading this, you probably already know who Toshiaki Kawada and Mitsuharu Misawa are and, even if this is a bit before each man's peak and before they became known as two of the Four Pillars, you also wouldn't be surprised that this is a total carry job as their opponents, known collectively as The Land of the Giants (admittedly, a sick name), are two huge stiffs. Skywalker Nitron went on to work as Big Sky, but he's mostly famous for playing Sabretooth in one of the X-Men movies and Michael Myers in Rob Zombie's Halloween. Butch Masters is a wrestler I'd never even heard of before so I was surprised to learn that he was active for 20+ years, wrestling as recently as 2012 with his earliest matches on Cagematch being from the late 80s. Anyway, Kawada and Misawa do a good job of making the monsters look like monsters and legitimate threats for most of the match, though once the tied turns, the momentum shifts entirely and its not long before Misawa and Kawada get the W. Really liked Kawada's dive to the floor and Misawa's final suplex. The crowd was also already super into Misawa, which I wasn't necessarily expecting in 90'. Not a very good match, not even a good match, but probably about as good as a Land of the Giants match could be. (1.5/5)


Tatsumi Fujinami vs. Dynamite Kid (08/17/1979, Stampede): This match was for the WWF Junior Heavyweight Championship, a title that dated back to the 1960s but was barely promoted in the US in the 80s. Fujinami was in the midst of a long reign at this point. Kid comes out swinging with some good-looking forearms and then grabs an arm after a nearfall. Fujinami breaks it by backing Dynamite into the ropes but gets his wrist locked up again and taken down to the mat. Dynamite turns it into a headlock but Fujinami counters it into a nifty ankle lock that does some damage. Kid gets free and does some terrific selling and then gets back body dropped and dropkicked soon after. Dynamite gets a takedown and grabs Fujinami's ankle, but Fujinami grabs hold of his chin, turning it into a body scissors. Kid breaks free and hits him with some more stiff forearms and a headbutt in the corner. A dragon suplex by Dynamite gets 2 but Fujinami gets hold of the ankle again and hyperextends it with a dragon screw before twisting it up again. Fujinami hits another dragon screw and Kid is in serious pain as Fujinami grapevines the leg once more and falls back repeatedly. This would be dull and repetitive if it weren't for how intense and realistic it all is, both guys putting a ton of emotion into the struggle. Fujinami goes for a cover but Kid kicks out quickly and then hobbles into the corner. They lock up again and Fujinami gets sent to the ropes. He hits a tackle and we get some leapfrogs and then a midair collision - a classic "double down." Fujinami slams Kid's head into the mat a few times and goes for a cover but only gets 2. He applies a bow-and-arrow but Kid grabs the ropes to break it. Kid hits a huge headbutt and both men go down, exhausted. A sunset flip by Fujinami gets 2 and Kid slams his head into the mat and goes for a cover, but Fujinami bridges and then catches Kid in a body scissors! Kid tries to pin his shoulders but Fujinami gets his arms up. Kid counters the body scissors into a submission of his own, sitting on Fujinami's calves. Fujinami manages to turn it over and both guys, in an incredible show of strength and grit, push up off the mat. Dynamite manages to get a half-crab but can't get the submission and goes to work on Fujinami's lower back. He tries for an inside cradle but only gets 2. Fujinami hits a gut-wrench suplex and tries for an underhook but Kid goes to the corner and fights his way out. Fujinami grabs hold of Dynamite's ankle but eats a heel kick. Dynamite sends Fujinami to the outside of frustration, the first time this match has left the ring after 15+ minutes of action. Dynamite goes to the second rope and drops down on Fujinami with a stomp and then applies a rear headlock. Fujinami gets to his feet and gets hit with another barrage of strikes and then a snap mare. Kid tries for some pins but only gets 2 and goes back to targeting Fujinami's lower back. Dynamite ties him up in the ropes and goes for a running kick but Fujinami escapes and he crotches himself! Dropkick by Fujinami! 1...2...Kid has his feet on the ropes. Dynamite delivers a body slam and an elbow drop and then another slam before heading to the top rope, his nose busted up. He tries for a diving headbutt but Fujinami catches him with a dropkick! Dynamite ends up on the floor and Fujinami dives through the middle ropes, catching him with at least part of his body (the camera doesn't quite capture it and it looks like Fujinami got tripped up a bit). They brawl on the outside and Fujinami ends up back in the ring to beat the count. This was really good but I wish it had a stronger finish. Watching this, you can see why these two guys are considered among the best of all time. Had this ended with something even close to definitive, I would consider this "must see." (3.5/5)


Buddy Landell and Cocoa Samoa vs. Tully Blanchard and Bob Roop (04/24/1982, Mid-South Wrestling): Seeing Landell without his platinum hair is a little weird. I'd never even heard of Cocoa Samoa before this. Landell and Blanchard start things off with some good, fast-paced wrestling and Blanchard getting all pissy, which is always great. In comes Roop and Samoa, who has a very similar presentation/get-up as his close personal friend Jimmy Snuka. Roop hits some nice tackles but Samoa regains controls with some brilliant arm drags. Its not the most innovative stuff, but it all looks great and Roop moves better than one might expect looking at his physique. Roop sends Samoa to the floor but he comes back with a springboard sunset flip for 2. Blanchard makes the tag and they do a test of strength with Samoa bringing him to the mat and then making a quick tag to Landell, who holds onto a tight headlock. Landell takes out both heels and they head to the floor to re-think strategy. Blanchard applies a headlock onto Roop and then tags back out to Samoa. In comes Blanchard to eat more chops but The heels take over and cut the ring in half, working him over in the corner. Roop tries for a pin but Samoa gets his foot on the rope. Blanchard comes back in and hits an elbow and then a knee drop for 2. Roop comes back in and drives a knee into Samoa's ribs and then tries for a cradle but only gets 2. Blanchard comes in but ends up eating the turnbuckle and Samoa makes the tag! Landell seems to be in control but a blind tag leads to Roop hitting the High Knee and then a leg drop for 3. The match only runs 7 minutes but its good for what it is. (2.5/5)


Roddy Piper vs. Jack Brisco (07/10/1982, Mid-Atlantic Championship Wrestling): I wouldn't say this match revealed anything new about Roddy Piper to me as much as it bolsters the argument that he could be very, very good against the right opponent and could get a ton of mileage out of doing "the little things" with a massive amount of energy and spirit. The extended headlock segment is probably the best use of a headlock I've ever seen in a wrestling match and I'm not sure anyone else could pull it off but these two. This is not a match that will impress modern viewers - there's simply not enough "high spots" - but its never boring or repetitive despite the straight-forward, rather simple offense. (3/5)


Tiger Mask II (Mitsuharu Misawa) and Jumbo Tsuruta vs. Genichiro Tenryu and Samson Fuyuki (01/14/1990, AJPW): I was a little surprised to see that this was from 1990 as I always thought Misawa's Tiger Mask run ended by then. As I've watched more AJPW/NOAH over the past year, I've come to recognize the structure of matches like this as the two legendary tough guys - Tsuruta and Tenryu - team up with the less-established Misawa (under the Tiger Mask hood) and Fuyuki with the younger guys eating a ton of punishment. The Tsuruta/Tenryu interactions got the biggest reactions, but Misawa was impressive here too, moving with an energy and style that made him stand out. The finish was excellent as Tsuruta applied a half-crab to Fuyuki, Tenryu nailed him with a clothesline, but because he held onto the move, it wrenched Fuyuki's knee even more and he was forced to submit. (3/5)



Hisako Uno (Akira Hokuto) and Yumiko Hotta vs. Kazue Nagahori and Yumi Ogura (04/27/1987, AJW): This is the infamous match where Hokuto (who was still going by Hisako Uno at this point) takes a piledrives from the second turnbuckle, breaks her neck and basically holds it in place whenever she's not still wrestling, finishing the remaining 2 falls of the match (its a 2-out-of-3 falls match for the WWWA Tag Team Championships held by Nagahori and Ogura). After Hokuto's injury, Hotta looks legitimately pissed and really lets loose with her kicks, knocking some of Ogura's teeth out with direct shots to her face/head. It is brutal stuff. This is a hard match to rate because its hard not to focus on Hokuto's toughness as, rather than just spending the rest of the match on the outside, she does actually get involved and take some bumps after the injury. The finish is pretty ugly and feels a bit "forced" as Hotta seems to get up multiple times just so her opponent can lay into her with a believable finishing kick, but none of them look like match-enders the way Hotta's do. A "must watch" for fans of Hokuto because this match is regarded as a critical part of her origin story, but not an all-time great match or anything. (3/5)


Negro Casas vs. El Hijo Del Santo (07/18/1987, WWA): I spent a ton of time in 2025 and 2026 watching classic AJPW and joshi (mostly AJW) and a little bit of NOAH to help me broaden my tastes and put together a more respectable ballot for the 2026 Greatest Wrestler Ever poll at ProWrestlingOnly. Originally, my goal was to also watch more lucha libre, which didn't end up happening as I never really got "hooked" by the genre. I'm not a quitter, though, so I'm planning on diving deeper into the works of El Hijo Del Santo and Casas, two guys that have popped on many, many GWE lists I've seen. Anyway...Negro Casas is terrific and might have one of the best worked punches I've ever seen. Its not that it looks particularly real, but it looks dramatic and impactful in the best way. They tell a very basic story with Casas getting the first fall and El Hijo, the hero, having to fight hard to win the match (and to hold onto his mask as this is a Mask vs. Hair bout). There's an incredible visual when Casas tries to rip El Hijo's mask off and the referee has to try to choke him to stop it. Non-stop action, super hot crowd, and some nifty sequences with Casas bumping like a madman. (3.5/5)


Akira Maeda vs. Yoshiaki Fujiwara (08/13/1989, UWF): As someone pretty unversed in shoot-style pro-wrestling, I went into this with an open mind and the hope that it would blow me away with the striking and realistic submissions/counter-wrestling. That didn't exactly happen, but I did enjoy it for what it was. Maeda eventually gets the win with a series of stiff kicks that Fujiwara can't recover from, which didn't feel like a dramatic enough finish to me (but, hey, I get that this particular genre of wrestling is more about realism than about dramatic finishes). If this match is considered one of the best shoot-style matches of all time, I'm not sure how interested I am in seeing much more of the genre. (3/5)


Hisako Uno (Akira Hokuto) and Yumiko Hotta vs. Judy Martin and Leilani Kai (04/15/1987, AJW): Another early pre-Hokuto Hokuto match that I meant to watch before I made my Greatest Wrestler Ever ballot but didn't get to. This is a 2-out-of-3 falls match for the vacant WWWA World Tag Team Championships with the foreigners dominating the first fall, the babyfaces getting a countout victory for the 2nd when Kai suffers an arm injury, and then all hell breaking loose as Dump Matsumoto shows up and bloodies Hotta while Martin takes out Hokuto with a chair. I really liked the fire that the babyfaces showed here but disliked that the interference from Matsumoto didn't end the match. I'm fully aware that 80s joshi often involves all sorts of weapon shots and interference that doesn't cause a disqualification, but during a match for a vacant championship, there should be at least some logic that the reason the heels have to play by the rules is because they can't rely on a count-out or DQ to help them retain the titles. This isn't a must-see, though it is evidence that, even early on, Hokuto was a special worker. Good stuff. (3/5)


Dustin Rhodes vs. Bobby Eaton (12/07/1991, WCW): The date on this match on YouTube is 12/7, but Cagematch has it listed as happening on 11/11 (maybe that is when it was taped?). Anyway, this is about what you'd expect, which is a strong TV match from Saturday Night. Jim Ross is doing commentary solo but I kinda dig it because he is not only doing the play-by-play but also providing some very good commentary with plenty of references to Eaton's rap sheet as a heel. Dustin puts on a great babyface performance, selling the heck out of the damage done to his knee by Eaton's attack (which includes some marvelous chair shots on the floor). I also really liked Madusa's involvement on the outside. This is the kind of "classic" match layout that nobody seems to do these days, or at least not enough, but if you listen to the crowd, the heat is definitely there and it would still be there today (as proven by how much heat Stokely gets now that he's managing FTR). Not a "must see" match, but solid. (3/5)


Jerry Estrada vs. La Parka (04/30/1995, AAA): Not the best tape quality, but I don't mind a little bit of grain. Fun start with La Parka showing off his quickness and technical ability with Estrada forced to play defense a bit. Estrada's timing and spacing seems a bit awkward at times. The referee shows his allegiance to Estrada, making an incredibly fast count for him after a sunset flip. Parka applies a leglock to start the second fall but the ref essentially breaks it up. The ref makes an incredibly slow count when La Parka goes for a cover but La Parka continues to control the match, hitting an array of really good high-flying moves. He nearly cripples himself on a crazy springboard something-or-other to the floor but then makes up for it with an excellent suicide dive. Wow. Parka makes it back to the ring and the referee is forced to complete the count, tying things up 1-1. La Parka goes for another dive but gets caught up in the ropes and Estrada returns to the ring to hit him with a neck breaker. A ref's distraction allows Estrada to maintain control, but Estrada doesn't keep the pressure on. There's some dead time before Estrada delivers a suicide dive on his own. La Parka crawls into the ring but then retreats again, firing up the crowd. Back in the ring, Estrada bodyslams La Parka and then goes to the top but misses a back splash. La Parka covers and the ref doesn't even make the count. Estrada basically just stands and waits for La Parka to kick him. La Parka does a fancy pin but Estrada gets his foot on the ropes. He hits him with a dropkick that sends him to the floor and then comes flying off the top with a crossbody to the floor! Between the dead time (most of it when Estrada should seemingly be on offense) and Estrada just standing around, this match is really carried by La Parka's performance. They manage to make it back in the ring and La Parka hits an awesome Alabama Slam out of the corner. He goes to the top but misses a dropkick and Estrada applies a quick submission to steal the W. This match is listed on YouTube as happening on 4/30/1995, but seemingly didn't air until 08/06/1995 according to Cagematch. (3/5)

Saturday, May 2, 2026

2026 Greatest Wrestler Ever List

2026 Greatest Wrestler Ever List

Starting in 2006, every 10 years, a few hundred wrestling nerds cast ballots online to decide The Greatest Wrestler Ever. The process is run by mega-fans at the ProWrestlingOnly message board but is open to anyone with enough free time to rank the top 100 professional wrestlers of all time. 

Over the past 20 months, I've watched probably close to 200 hours to help inform my ballot on top of my usual diet of AEW pay-per-views, full-length TNA events on YouTube, and, up until fairly recently, WWE PLEs. Now that I'm done with this project, I'm excited to go on a lengthy break from wrestling.

The list below, the list I came up with, bothers me in places. There are rankings in it that frustrate me and wrestlers that I wish weren't on it. I too am shocked that Batista earned a spot and The Great Muta didn't or that somehow Seth Rollins outranks Sabu even though I'd rather watch a bad Sabu match than a good Seth Rollins match. But I went into this project with a system of self-imposed rules and criterion and I tried to stick to it in an effort to do more than just list my favorite wrestlers, which is not the point of the exercise (that list would look very different and undoubtedly include Mikey Whipwreck and Psicosis and Buddy Landell). 

*******

1. Terry Funk 

2. Steve Austin
I had Austin at #1 in 2016. 

3. Bryan Danielson

4. Ric Flair

5. Rey Mysterio Jr.

6. AJ Styles
AJ is the most influential wrestler of the past 25 years. 

7. Bret Hart

8. Eddie Guerrero

9. Shawn Michaels

10. Randy Savage

11. Brock Lesnar

12. CM Punk

13. Mitsuharu Misawa
One of my goals over the past two years was to watch the many hallowed classics of Japanese wrestling that I'd never seen before. I watched a fraction of them and almost all of it was 80s and 90s All Japan Pro-Wrestling (AJPW) and All Japan Women's Pro Wrestling (AJW), which is why you won't find any of the major Japanese stars from New Japan or NOAH or FMW on here. 

14. Bull Nakano

15. Toshiaki Kawada

16. Kenta Kobashi

17. Mick Foley

18. Ricky Steamboat

19. Chris Jericho
I've had little to no interest in seeing Chris Jericho talk or wrestle in a few years, but in the 90s and 00s, he was consistently good-to-great and, at multiple points in his career, the best act in whichever company he was in. 

20. Kevin Steen 

21. Sami Zayn

22. Samoa Joe
I wish I could ignore the years where Samoa Joe was booked so poorly in TNA that he looked completely checked out.

23. Kenny Omega

24. Christian

25. Akira Hokuto

26. Aja Kong

27. Kurt Angle

28. The Rock 

29. Cesaro (Claudio Castignoli)

30. Kyoko Inoue
She rules and I'm surprised I haven't seen her on more people's lists.

31. Sasha Banks (Mercedes Mone)

32. Arn Anderson

33. John Cena
Yes, I think Arn Anderson, Christian, and Cesaro are all better pro-wrestlers than John Cena. 

34. Shinya Hashimoto
"Discovering" Shinya Hashimoto two years ago was one of the best parts of this project.

35. Jushin Liger

36. Manami Toyota

37. Vader
Through this project, I learned post-WWE Vader is actually pretty good.

38. Asuka (Kana) 

39. William Regal

40. Owen Hart

41. Jon Moxley

42. GUNTHER

43. Dustin Rhodes 

44. Hulk Hogan

45. Roman Reigns

46. Bobby Eaton 

47. Curt Hennig

48. Chris Benoit 

49. Will Ospreay
Having Will Ospreay ranked above Roddy Piper will anger any "old school" wrestling fan reading this and probably ruin any credibility I have as a "smart" wrestling fan, but Ospreay is a fireworks show personified, the guy who took on the mantle from Omega (who took it from AJ who took it from Shawn who took it from...) in terms of pushing the athletic boundaries of pro-wrestling.

50. Roddy Piper

51. Tully Blanchard

52. Finn Balor (Prince Devitt)

53. Brian Pillman

54. La Parka (LA Park)
One of my goals for this project was to watch more lucha libre. It didn't happen, but I did see enough to recognize how great La Parka is.

55. Rick Rude

56. Barry Windham

57. Nick Bockwinkel
Before 2 years ago, I'd never seen a Nick Bockwinkel match. He's terrific.

58. Sting

59. Jeff Hardy

60. Yoshihiro Tajiri

61. Darby Allin
Darby Allin was tough to rank because he blew up my "system." His matches are always entertaining. He's great against a variety of opponents. He's good at hardcore brawls but can also straight-up wrestle. His offense is believable despite his size. He's got undeniable charisma, a cool look, and is a great underdog babyface. He's good in singles, tags, six-mans, even battle royals. He rules.

62. Stan Hansen
Having a "stunt man" like Darby Allin ranked higher than Stan Hansen would anger some people.

63. IYO SKY (Io Shirai)

64. Genichiro Tenryu
Prior to my extensive GWE viewing, I thought Tenryu was one of the dullest wrestlers ever because, growing up, I'd only really seen him at WrestleMania VII. I was way off.

65. Sean Waltman (Lightning Kid/1-2-3 Kid/Syxx)

66. Shane "Swerve" Strickland

67. Diamond Dallas Page
Underrated, incredibly creative performer who put more thought into 6-minute filler matches than others do for their 30-minute "epics."

68. Fit Finlay

69. "Hangman" Adam Page

70. Charlotte Flair
I have a soft spot for wrestlers whose matches can either be incredible or complete car crashes - like a Brock Lesnar or a Hashimoto - and Charlotte brings that same intensity and emotion to her matches.

71. Sheamus

72. Seth Rollins
I don't like Seth Rollins. I kinda think he sucks. But I've reviewed about 90 matches of his and the vast majority of good-to-great. I wish I could keep him off this list.

73. Triple H
A summary of my feelings about Triple H would be near-identical to what I wrote about Seth Rollins. 

74. Rhea Ripley

75. The Undertaker

76. Akira Taue 
The lowest ranking of the Four Pillars of AJPW, but also the Pillar I've watched the least of.

77. Yoshinari Ogawa
Terrific wrestler that is very easy to appreciate even if you're new to Japanese wrestling, which I was when I started my GWE viewing. 

78. Jumbo Tsuruta

79. Cody Rhodes

80. Randy Orton

81. Edge (Adam Copeland)

82. Matt Hardy

83. Drew McIntyre

84. Konosuke Takeshita
One of my favorite wrestlers to watch over the past 3-4 years.

85. Becky Lynch

86. Rob Van Dam
No 90s kid could leave RVD off their list, though his work after 2006-or-so is rough.

87. Ricochet

88. Luke Harper (Brodie Lee) 

89. Bayley
 
90. Batista

91. Dean Malenko
Yes, I have Dave Batista ranked higher than Dean Malenko and it makes me shake my head too.

92. Jeff Jarrett

93. Ted DiBiase

94. Lex Luger

95. Dolph Ziggler

96. Zack Sabre Jr. 

97. Davey Boy Smith

98. Scott Hall (Razor Ramon)

99. Alex Shelley

100. Sabu

Saturday, April 25, 2026

Random Matches


Manami Toyota and Toshiyo Yamada vs. Etsuko Mita and Mima Shimoda (06/17/1996, AJW): Reading up the LCO, I found it interesting (though not that odd in Japanese wrestling) to learn that, at one point, Yamada and Mita held the AJW Tag Team Championships and that Toyota and Shimoda were a team as well. Anyway...the LCO come out of the gate with offense as Mita goes after Toyota, hitting her with a quick piledriver and trying to choke her out. In comes Shimoda, who uses the ropes to choke Toyota before applying a snug Tongan Death Grip on the mat and then another piledriver. Toyota won't go down easy, though, and a slapfight ensues. Shimoda works on Toyota's hand for a bit before tagging in Mita. Toyota lands a springboard crossbody and then tags out to Yamada. Yamada has a hell of a kick, really punishing Mita's back. The LCO regain control and Shimoda comes back in to apply a camel clutch and then a body scissors to Yamada. Toyota breaks it up with a dropkick and then comes into the match for a 2-on-1 slam. Toyota goes to the top rope but gets suplexed down by Shimoda for 2. Mita has a chair and, damn, they absolutely crack Toyota in the head with it! Damn. Shimoda then grabs a pair of scissors and drives them into Toyota's head! Chair shot to Yamada! Wow, that escalated quickly. Toyota is cut on her forehead and, like the true experts they are, Mita and Shimoda essentially parade her around all four sides of the ring so the audience can see it. The babyfaces get whipped into the guardrails on the outside and Toyota is now an absolute bloody mess. Toyota fights back there, pulling Shimoda by the hair and tossing her into the rail and the crowd. Shimoda and Mita utilize more chairs, though, and then Shimoda puts a table into the ring. On the outside, Yamada sends Mita into the crowd and hits her with a chair but Mita throws it back into her face. In the ring, the LCO powerbomb Toyota on the flattened table! Damn. They mock the crowd's chanting of "Toyota" and then Shimoda hits her with a suplex for 2. In comes Mita, who attempts a powerbomb but almost gets pinned. Toyota manages to hit a German suplex of her own and then a moonsault but her pin attempt is broken up by another chair attack from Shimoda. Shimoda accidentally clocks her own partner, though, and the babyfaces take control! Double back suplex off the top rope by Toyota and Yamada onto Mita! Brutal head drop there! It only gets 2 so Toyota hits her with the Electric Chair for 2. The LCO regains control and we get another close fall after a Death Valley Driver by Mita onto Yamada. Missile dropkick off the top by Toyota but Shimoda clobbers her with a chair. Yamada tries a crossbody off the top but Mita catches her with a chair. Yamada manages to get another near fall and hits an absolutely awesome spinning front kick off the ropes. Another DVD by Shimoda, though, and this one is over! Wow. This started out okay, then became absolutely wild, and then ended with a really impressive finishing stretch. (3.5/5)


"Speedball" Mike Bailey vs. Zack Sabre Jr. (01/26/2018, Defiant Wrestling): This match was for Sabre Jr.'s Defiant Wrestling Internet Championship. The story coming in was that Bailey had a weakened knee, making him especially vulnerable to ZSJ's vaunted repertoire of submissions. A good match and a good juxtaposition of styles with Bailey's offense being based on kicks and speed and high-flying and Zack Sabre Jr. being a submission specialist. I would've liked more long-term selling by Bailey, but him "ignoring" the leg damage wasn't so egregious that it ruined the match or anything. Good match. (3/5)


Davey Boy Smith vs. Kenta Kobashi (01/26/1990, AJPW): Nothing special here, though there is some fun seeing these two guys in 1990 when, 4-5 years later, they'd both be much bigger stars. Smith is clearly "on the gas" at this point, looking massive. According to Cagematch, a week earlier, Bulldog had teamed with Dynamite to take on Kobashi and Tiger Mask (Misawa, I'm guessing?). Not much to say about this match aside from it being captured on "fan cam" and that it only goes about 10 minutes with very few highlights. Smith shows off his power in a few spots, but this a mostly technical affair that is kept in the ring and fought fairly. Compared to the heavyweight matches going on in the WWE or WCW, this was probably a step-up for the time but compared to both men's better output, it doesn't rank highly. (2.5/5)



Manami Toyota vs. Kaoru Ito (08/09/1997, AJW): Another really strong Manami Toyota. She is fantastic in this; all of her offense is incredibly well-executed (including multiple springboards that had me wondering if she doesn't have the best "springboard" of any wrestler in history) and her suplexes look nasty. I was less familiar with Kaoru Ito, but her use of double stomps is vicious. Loved the nearly-endless rolling pin from Toyota early. One review on PWO notes that this has a "B match" feel in that it isn't as epic as Toyota's more famous matches, but I don't think that's a criticism as much as proof of her greatness because, for most anybody else, this would probably a Top 10 match. (3.5/5)



Shinya Hashimoto vs. Genichiro Tenryu (06/08/1999, NJPW): Right from the start this is a battle of two big, strong men who know each other well, with even their lock-ups early on being intense before they start trading overhand strikes and chops. Early highlights include Tenryu landing a powerbomb early before getting dropkicked on the apron, a bunch of trademark kicks from Hash, and Tenryu leveling Hashimot with his sharp jabs after cutting him off with a well-placed knee to the groin. Hashimoto's selling is excellent and keeps the somewhat repetitive offense from ever feeling dull. Hashimoto ends up on the top rope and nails Tenryu with an awesome kick to gain control but his enziguiri doesn't quite connect. Tenryu's stubborn defiance leads to a strike exchange that ends with a Hashimoto DDT for 2. He tries for a suplex but Tenryu counters it into a DDT of his own that leaves both men on the mat. Hash hits a running enzigiuri but Tenryu shrugs it off and we get another series of big chops, both men taking incredible punishment. It takes three big clotheslines to bring Hashimoto to the mat for another near fall but Hashimoto gets up quicker and hits some more big kicks that leave Tenryu dazed and hanging on the ropes. A spinning back hand from Hashimoto sends Tenryu to the corner and Hash, after some serious struggle, lands an absolutely nasty brain buster. I'm not sure if he was going for a vertical suplex but he barely gets him up for it and Tenryu ends up landing on his hand. Hashimoto gets merciless from there but Tenryu finds an opening for another jab, forcing Hashimoto to unload his own stiff punches (as opposed to his usual overhand chops). We get another strike exchange but this time its Tenryu who finishes it with a rolling heel kick and then another big chop off the ropes to end it. The finish felt a little bit out of nowhere to me as Tenryu's big chop didn't seem like a "match ender" after seeing them hit each other with dozens of them over the course of the match. A better, more definitive finish would've bumped this up for me but this was still pretty awesome. (3.5/5)


Kenta Kobashi vs. Toshiaki Kawada (06/12/1998, AJPW): Watching AJPW out of sequence and with no understanding of context can actually help your enjoyment of a match sometimes - or at least it might have here. Reading up on this a bit, Kobashi and Kawada had had some epic battles in the past, including a 60-minute draw, and a bunch of acclaimed matches earlier in the 90s. Kawada was coming off a huge victory over Misawa, a win that he had been chasing for years, and this was his first defense of the Triple Crown Championship. Kobashi and Kawada beat the living hell out of each other in this match, just absolutely laying into each other with strikes and chops and head-drop suplexes. At various times, both men look like they are wrestling through concussions and I'm not sure they weren't. So much struggle, so many nasty Kobashi lariats, so much emotion, so many brilliant cut-offs and even some very good use of submissions by Kawada - this match has it all and it is all done well. This match doesn't have the same reputation for being a "Greatest Match Ever" candidate the way some of Misawa, Kawada, and Kobashi's other matches do, but I'm not even sure why. This is an absolutely awesome match that delivers on every level. (5/5)



Kota Ibushi vs. Jushin Thunder Liger (06/13/2009, NJPW): A disappointing match in that it felt like two different matches jammed together. The first 10 minutes see Liger dominate on the mat with submissions targeting Ibushi's leg and, for that first 10-12 minutes, Ibushi does an excellent job of selling it. It's not the most riveting set-up but it sets the table for what I presumed to be a big Ibushi-on-one-leg comeback. Instead, Ibushi ends up shrugging off the selling almost entirely and going into "fireworks" mode with his offense, flipping all over the place. Ibushi's offense is so impressive that its hard to complain too much, but as an overall story, I found it to be a bit lazy. (2.5/5)



Kazuchika Okada and Hiroyoshi Tenzan vs. Kenta Kobashi and Akihiko Ito (05/06/2009, NOAH): I wasn't expecting much of out of this match - it made my "Watchlist" mostly based on my desire to see more Okada and Kobashi as I prepare to make my Greatest Wrestler Ever list - but this was a ton of a fan and I loved Kobashi's attitude from the beginning, basically begging his opponents to bring their A-game and bullying his own partner, Ito, into matching his level of intensity. The way Okada bumps for Kobashi's lariats (while Kobashi practically no-sells an Okada dropkick) make for some great moments. I'm unfamiliar with Hiroyoshi Tenzan but he had a ton of attitude and energy. Not a classic or anything, but Kobashi's performance nudges it above average. (3/5)



Kyoko Inoue vs. Yumiko Hotta (08/20/1997, AJW): I was surprised to see this match getting fairly low ratings over on Cagematch, well below the 4.5 stars that Meltzer gave it in the Observer. It's not an all-time classic (which a match rated 4.5 stars in 1997 should be as this was well before Meltzer "blew up" his own rating system), but its one of the better Hotta matches I've seen and Kyoko Inoue is very good here too. Some really nifty powerbombs and Hotta's armbar looks terrific. The match doesn't overstay its welcome but all feels very "complete" and like its been a fight from beginning to end. The crowd is into it. Maybe not "must see," but well above average. (3.5/5)



Timothy Thatcher vs. Zack Sabre Jr. (04/13/2025, DEFY): A bit of a weird watch in 2025. In terms of the action, it is highly technical and mat-based and there's lots of joint manipulation and submission work, which is exactly one might suspect. In a sense, they are giving you what their reputations advertise they will give you...but the match never exceeds or subverts those expectations, which feels maybe a bit underwhelming in 2025, especially from Sabre Jr., who has added so much more to his arsenal than just his mat work and that was kinda missing here. That's not to say that this isn't a superb exhibition of grit and technique - the intensity and animosity on display is undoubtedly terrific - but that it just didn't pull me in emotionally at all. (3/5)



Will Ospreay vs. Konosuke Takeshita (04/16/2025, AEW): These two had a match I really liked at Revolution 2024. This one started off a bit tepid but picks up after the commercial break and the last few minutes are absolutely insane with finisher steals, 2.9999 kickouts, and crazy counters. The live crowd eats it all up, but aside from being impressed with the execution of their respective offense, this match didn't hook me in any emotionally meaningful way. So many Oscutters, so many Hidden Blades...and none of it "weighed" anything by the end. This match has an insane rating on Cagematch that it doesn't deserve, but there are also plenty of commenters who found this to be overloaded with high spots and false finishes. (2.5/5)



Will Ospreay vs. Claudio Castignoli (12/11/2024, AEW): Good start to this match with Castignoli showing off his agility a bit before using power to take control of the match. Cesaro swings Fletcher into the steps before using them to torture Ospreay's arm. Claudio applies a Sharpshooter but then goes seamlessly into a crossface and then, with a bit more struggle, back into a Sharpshooter during the picture-in-picture segment. The crowd gets restless as Ospreay manages to untangle himself and get some offense in, including a big boot in the corner and then a vertical suplex. Ospreay calls for the Hidden Blade but Claudio gets his boot up. Ospreay applies an Octopus Hold but Claudio gets to the ropes. Claudio hits a double stomp to Ospreay's back and then dead lifts Ospreay up for a slam. They go to the top rope and Claudio gets headbutted to the mat, allowing Ospreay to attempt a sidetwister - but Claudio evades it and hits him with a running uppercut instead. After a brief strike exchange, Ospreay lands the Oscutter, but Claudio rolls to the outside to avoid getting pinned. Ospreay goes for another Hidden Blade but Claudio catches him with a pop-up uppercut and then hits a lariats for a near fall. Claudio looks to hit his finish, but Ospreay jackknife pins him out of nowhere! Very unexpected finish. After the match, Claudio got a little bit of his heat back by attacking Ospreay. When Castignoli went to grab a chair, though, Darby Allin ran out for the save. Even though they did way less "stuff," I liked the story of this match better than the Takeshita one. (3/5)



Aja Kong vs. Manami Toyota (10/6/1996, AJW): Manami tries her best to get some offense in out of the gate with springboards and sprints around the ring, but Kong grounds her with ease and applies a body scissors. Kong gets to her feet and starts to hit her with stiff kicks. This might be one of the loudest matches i've ever seen with lots of screaming out of Toyota. Kong stomps on her, snap mares her, and then applies a headlock. Toyota pulls on Kong's ear to break the hold. She does some headbutts, but Kong headbutts back and Toyota ends up on the mat. Kong applies a camel clutch and its a punishing-looking one, but Toyota uses all of her energy to spring back. Kong turns it into a modified surfboard and then unloads more stiff kicks. Toyota manages to get a nearfall on a sunset flip and then counters another Kong submission into a choke of her own. Kong escapes and lifts Toyota up in a choke before dropping her. Toyota bridges out of a pin attempt, but Kong just squashes her! Kong hits the catapult-backbreaker, one of my favorite combos, and then catapults her neck-first into the bottom rope. To the outside they go, with Kong tossing her into some chairs (and fans). Both women ram their heads into the post to prove their toughness/psych themselves up. Kong hits devastating pile-driver on the floor. Toyota manages to get into the ring and Kong calls for a test of strength, but Manami mocks her a little bit by reaching her hand up higher, showing off her height advantage. They trade blows and Kong knocks her to the ground, but when she goes for a pop-up something, Toyota starts to unload her dropkicks, the last one connecting to the back of Kong's head and sounding like a gunshot. Damn. Toyota applies an Octopus Hold but Kong is able to step across the ring with her on her back and reach the ropes. Toyota goes back up to top and tries a crossbody but Kong catches her and drops her to the mat. Stalling jumping piledriver! Goddamn. Moments later, Kong rolls to the outside from a dropkicks and Toyota attempts her springboard splash to the outside but gets met with a kick to the ribs. Kong sends her into the guardrail and then back into the ring. Kong goes to the top rope but Manami meets her there and dropkicks her off and to the floor! Toyota brings a table over the rail and puts Kong on it. Springboard somersault legdrop but the table doesn't break and Toyota ends up bumping to the floor on the back of her head! Holy cow. Toyota rolls her back into the ring and goes for a German suplex but Kong blocks it. Kong with an unbelievable sit out powerbomb! Wow. Kong goes for a back suplex but Toyota escapes and hits the German for 2! She tries a moonsault but Kong gets her feet up! Back suplex right onto Toyota's neck by Kong! A body slam leads to a nasty splash from the top rope but Toyota bridges out! Kong goes back up top but Toyota follows her up! Sunset flip powerbomb, but again Toyota takes the worst of it as Kong lands on her lap more than the ring. Ugly stuff, but I kinda like that in my pro-wrestling. Toyota tries for the straightjacket suplex but eats a brainbuster instead. Kong hoists her up to the top rope and Toyota tries for another powerbomb but ends up with Kong landing on top of her. Toyota bridges out of another pin attempt. Toyota escapes Kong's first attempt at a suplex but gets hit by one anyway. Kong goes to the top, which allows Toyota to set her up for the Electric Chair suplex for 2! Great nearfall. Both women are staggering....Uranake! But Kong can't capitalize, unable to make the cover as Toyota rolls to the bottom rope. She gets a pin, but Toyota bridges out once more! Toyota springs to life and hits a beautiful German Suplex but can't hold onto the pin. Kong gets to her feet and goes for another Uranake but Toyota blocks it and hits a German Suplex! She gets the pin, though Kong's foot clearly hits the bottom rope. Fun match with some glaring non-selling out of Toyota that I didn't love, but lots of little moments and counters that I did, including some outright comedic elements that I was not at all expecting. (3.5/5)



Kenny Omega/Chris Jericho/Kota Ibushi/Paul Wight vs. Konosuke Takeshita/Brian Cage/Kyle Fletcher/Powerhouse Hobbs (11/15/2023, AEW): This match, hyped as a "Like A Dragon Streetfight" (based on a video game I'd never heard of) starts off "wonky" and basically stumbles its way into watchability. Omega and Ibushi force a Golden Lovers spot that exposes Ibushi (and Brian Cage) a good bit due to poor execution. They had to book around Paul Wight's obvious mobility issues by having him get taken out in the back from a Powerhouse Hobbs slam that looked legitimately painful, but also would make one wonder why he was even booked in the match in the first place. Kyle Fletcher was not yet a show-stealer and is lost in this match. The use of bicycles as weapons was different. I liked some of the work towards the end with Omega and Jericho teaming up to take out Hobbs (and also the wicked bump Omega took into a plastic pallet earlier in the match), but this was not a great match and certainly not a 4+ star match like Meltzer rated it at the time. This was like a C-level "Stadium Stampede" match. (2.5/5)



Aja Kong vs. Megumi Kudo (12/06/1993, AJW): Cool match showcasing Megumi Kudo's toughness and submission skills as she challenges Kong for the 3WA Championship. Kong is equally great in this, dishing out serious punishment in the forms of kicks and suplexes. There were far fewer high spots in this than the last Kong match I watched (see above), but I dug the realism and strategy here just as much - or maybe even more? - than the higher workrate (but less selling) in that match. The match goes over 20 minutes and never feels dull or like they are repeating themselves. I was really surprised that we got a ref bump in this match that led to a visual pin as, based on my somewhat limited viewing (but still quite a bit at this pint), I don't think I've ever seen that before in a joshi match. Very good match, maybe just a hair short of "great." (3.5/5)



Keith Lee vs. Zack Sabre Jr. (11/06/2016, Beyond Wrestling): Beyond Wrestling is a promotion based out of Worcester, Massachusetts. This was a fun match with Lee and Sabre both trash-talking each other and the crowd, letting their clashes in style and presentation and personality do much of the heavy lifting. Sabre tries to wear Lee down with his grappling, but Lee is just too big and strong, especially in the early going. Over time, Sabre's striking and work on Lee's legs allows him to gain the upperhand for a few stretches, but Lee continuously cuts him off to maintain control. There were some good spots towards the end - the release guerilla press slam, Lee hitting an impressive crossbody, a kickout from Lee that sends Sabre halfway across the ring - and I liked the shocking finish, which featured one of Sabre's trademark nifty pins. Good stuff. (3/5)



Rhea Ripley vs. Jade Cargill (04/19/2026, WWE): I didn't watch all of WrestleMania this year for the first time in well over a decade (and even the rare WrestleManias I missed watching live or within a few days over the past 35 years, I have since gone back and watched in their entirety). There are multiple reasons for that, but I won't get into them here. Anyway...this was one of the very few matches I was intrigued by because, going into it, I assumed it would either be a very good match or a trainwreck (not dissimilar to Stratton/Charlotte, which ended up being a mix of both but was far more entertaining than this). Aside from the entrances, there was nothing special about this. With most WrestleMania matches, you can assume that the participants have likely gone over and, in many cases, rehearsed certain sequences so this is not an indictment of any particular worker, but this was a match where the "seams" showed and nothing felt organic or spontaneous. They only got 10 minutes so there wasn't much of a story or building up of drama before Cargill's entourage - Michin and B-Fab - showed up to try to help her steal the win. IYO SKY came out to make the save which led to the finishing sequence. Ripley reversing Cargill's finisher into a Ripcord was a solid ending of an unremarkable match, which probably makes it - for better or worse - one of the better matches of Cargill's short career but not really a feather in Ripley's cap. (2.5/5)



CM Punk vs. Roman Reigns (04/19/2026, WWE): I went into this match not sure what to expect, though I worried it might be filled with needless dialogue and potentially even outside interference in an effort to launch some sort of major storyline (and protect either man in a loss). Fortunately, Reigns and Punk delivered one of the better straight-up WrestleMania main events in quite some time, a match that built up slow and told a familiar story of CM Punk, the grizzled veteran, showing incredible determination and toughness in the face of an elite challenger with tremendous power and poise. With a runtime of over 30 minutes without a single minute of it seeming boring or like they were intentionally keeping their foot off the gas, this match showcased both men's strengths as in-ring performers - Punk's dynamic offense and believable selling, Roman's ability to convincingly be dominant or vulnerable as the situation requires and strong sense of timing and pacing his undeniably limited bag of signature moves. The second half of the match picked up considerably once Punk was denied an elbow drop through the table and ended up hanging from the top rope, exposing himself to a Superman punch that led to some "color" on his forehead. Reigns powerbombed him through the table minutes later but Punk fought back valiantly, kicking out of a huge Spear. A frustrated Reigns opted to slam Punk's head in the mat repeatedly and then signaled for GTS but Punk blocked it, hit him with a kick for 2, and then delivered a solid-enough Superman Punch for another nearfall. Punk went into the crowd and grabbed an ula fala, mocking the challenger in a heelish move, but ended up getting caught a guillotine when he tried for a spear. Punk managed to escape it to apply the Anaconda Vice but Reigns punched his way out and re-applied the guillotine. Punk escaped by kneeing Reigns in the groin and attempted a Sharpshooter but got locked in the guillotine again! Punk tried to turn it into a pin but only got 2 and we got the classic double clothesline "double down," a staple of "big match" layouts but also a spot with a ton of WrestleMania significance. From there, Punk hit a low blow to show how far he was willing to go to defeat Reigns and managed to hit his flying elbow through the table after all. Back in the ring, he hit Reigns with a GTS and Reigns bounced into the ropes before falling back onto Punk's shoulders for another GTS. This time Punk collapsed and Reigns hit him with a series of spears to secure a 100% clean victory. Tremendous match. (4/5)



Aja Kong vs. Dynamite Kansai (08/30/1995, AJW): This is another Aja Kong 3WA Championship defense. Kong comes in looking to put a hurting on Kansai, but Kansai stares her down, completely unafraid. Kong lifts her up and puts her in the corner and Kansai attempts a sunset flip powerbomb but gets squashed instead on a back body drop. Kong starts dishing out kicks but Kansai brings her down with a headlock. Kong dishes out some headlocks and chest chops but Kansai rallies with strikes of her own...that Kong no-sells. A strike exchange ends with both women dishing out headbutts and Kansai working Kong over with kicks before applying a Sharpshooter. Kansai turns it into an STF but can't get it fully locked in and Kong reaches the ropes. Kansai tries a camel clutch but Kong gets her arm free and reaches the rope. Kansai continues her attack and Kong is completely dazed and overwhelmed as Kansai applies a rear-naked choke. Back on her feet, Kong takes some more kicks but then rallies with some of her own, clocking Kansai in the head and putting her on defense. The final kick nails her in the face but Kansai gets back to her feet. Kong delivers a vertical suplex for 2 and then a stalling piledriver for another nearfall. Kansai tries for a roundhouse in the corner but gets caught on the top rope instead and Kong kicks her in the back of the thigh. Kong misses a splash, giving Kansai a chance but she takes another back body drop for 2. Kong lands the splash this time but Kansai kicks out again. Kansai counters a suplex but ends up dropped back on the mat again, unable to hit any sort of sustained offense. Kansai is stumbling around so Kong catches her and hits her with a high angle slam and then a fall away elbow for another pair of near falls. Kong calls for the Uranake but Kansai ducks it, sweeps her legs, and then nails her with a direct kick to the head to give herself a moment to breathe. Kansai comes running out of the corner but steps right into an Uranake! Kong's forehead is busted open but she maintains control, hoisting Kansai to the top rope. Kansai gets down and hits her with another kick to the head and tries for a powerbomb or pile-driver but can't get it, eating a strike to the head instead. Kong goes up to the top rope but Kansai gets beneath her and hits a sit-out Razor's Edge powerbomb! Wow! Kong kicks out at 2! Kansai lifts her back onto the top rope but Kong elbows her in the face and gets down. She tries for another Uranake but Kansai repeatedly kicks her in the hand and arm and Kong goes to the outside. She gets her arm sprayed with some sort of medicine and then even has her arm pulled back into place and bandaged before she goes back into the ring. Kansai meets her with more stiff kicks targeting her arm and Kong goes down! Kong escapes a piledriver attempt and tries for more Uranakes but Kansai keeps cutting her off with kicks! Kansai finally lands a powerbomb and then hoists Kong up onto the top rope for another Razor's Edge and that does it! I didn't particularly love the finish - which felt, very strangely, a touch too "cooperative" - and parts of this got a bit repetitive, but the realism was breathtaking and the psychology was terrific with Kansai focusing on stopping Kong's Uranake. More evidence of Aja's general awesomeness. (3/5)



Rey Fenix vs. Will Ospreay (09/02/2016, PWG): Hearing Excalibur on commentary for this gives it a proto-AEW feel, as does the red-hot crowd. As one might expect, this is a feast of high-flying from the jump with dropkicks and handsprings and springboards galore. Highlights included an insane springboard twisting splash by Fenix to the floor, an expertly-executed anti-aerial dropkick from Ospreay, and Fenix hitting a leaping superkick and following it up with a crazy Frankensteiner off the top rope. Ospreay slows things down with a headlock at one point, but it feels a little forced, like the two were checking it off a list of match components rather than it being a strategic move. This was part of a tournament so it makes sense that they would leave some of their signature stuff on the table - the match goes a little over 10 minutes - but it still feels like a complete match. Ospreay hits a series of lightning-fast offense to get a near fall and continues to control the tempo until Fenix cuts him off with a springboard Superman Punch from the middle rope. This leads to an overtly-cooperative Spanish Fly spot in which both men land on their feet, which causes the crowd to lose their collective mind. Not my thing due to the clear choreography, but I could see why this would get a massive pop from the PWG faithful. Ospreay ends up hitting the Standing Spanish Fly instead but misses his twisting, spinning kick and eats an Oscutter. Fenix applies the Dragon Sleeper but Ospreay gets to his feet. Fenix flips him into his shoulder and drops him with an over-the-shoulder pile-driver! 1..2..kickouts at 2.8. The commentator notes that that was Rikishi's finishing move, which explains why it looked familiary. Fenix goes for a double-spring 450 but Ospreay gets his knees up. He tries for a cover but only gets 2. Twisting, spinning kick and now Ospreay hits the Oscutter and gets the 3. I don't think this deserved the 4.5 stars Meltzer gave it or even the 8.5 rating on Cagematch as, despite the incredible offense on display, there's not any real emotional weight. I'm also not a fan of clear partnership and choreography and the Spanish Fly spot was especially blatant. Above average, for sure, but not must-see. (3/5)



Mayumi Ozaki vs. Megumi Kudo (04/18/1997, FMW): This was a No Ropes Barbed Wire Double Hell Death Match, which I was not actually aware of when I put this on my Greatest Wrestler Ever Watchlist. I usually really love Ozaki's death matches, but this was good-not-great in terms of match structure and drama. Instead of building up to the big spots or some sort of crescendo of violence, this match moves along at a fairly even pace with lots of small moments of craziness spread throughout. To me, matches like this need to feature iconic moments or stunning visuals and this fell a little short of offering more than one or two. I'll also readily admit that, like the reviewers on Cagematch, the version of this match I saw was trimmed down by a good 4-5 minutes so maybe that's why it feels a little bit "off" as a viewing experience. (2.5/5)


Roderick Strong vs. Will Ospreay (07/18/2015, SWE): As someone who was really introduced to Will Ospreay through AEW, I never understood how he could be seen as such a divisive - and outright hated - wrestler among fans. A match like this does a good job of illustrating why as, despite featuring some very good individual spots and execution of impressive high-flying maneuvers by Ospreay, its not all that good. Strong tries his best to build a story and play to the crowd, who are admittedly rabidly pro-Ospreay and eager to root on their hometown hero, but this feels like, the longer it goes, the less interesting or intense it becomes. They start things off relatively slow, which builds some tension, but as they start dishing out signature moves and counters and all the tricks they know, it becomes too choreographed and exhibition-y for me. Both guys would go on to have much better matches against other opponents when they focused more on the emotional story of a match and how to make shifts in momentum come off as organic rather than just showcasing their respective agility and technique. A fireworks show that was somehow dull. (2/5)


Mima Shimoda and Etsuko Mita vs. Kyoko Inoue and Aja Kong (08/09/1997, AJW): Shimoda and Mita were collectively known as the LCO and had a reputation for weapon usage and it does not take long before we see that on full display, though its Kong and Inoue who strike first, instigating a wild brawl on the outside before the bell can even be rung. Its bonkers and awesome. Seeing Awesome Kong getting brained by a chair is a slight to behold and it happens in the first 3 minutes. The match starts in earnest with Inoue and Mita going at it while Kong makes her way back to the ring looking absolutely pissed. Hair toss by Shimoda that actually looks incredibly vicious! Holy cow! Piledriver by Shimoda as Kong watches on with disdain (and blood trickling down her forehead). 5 minutes in and this is incredible. Kong comes in and dishes out headbutts, but because of the earlier chair shot, it actually hurts her as well (good psychology there). A fan or a second gets on the apron and Inoue just wails on them! Mita bites on Inoue's arm but gets hit with a beautiful DDT and then in comes Kong to hit a series of brutal kicks to the back. After a brief exchange of punches, Kong hits a clothesline in the corner. Mita rakes at her eyes and Shimoda tries to choke her out with a towel. Love the heel work there. In comes Shimoda, who bites Kong's forehead but gets cut-off with a body block off the ropes. I'm not sure what the story is between these two teams but this is seriously intense. Kong with a series of snap mares in which she pulls Shimoda by her long hair! Brutal! In comes Kyoko with a chair and she cracks Shimoda in the head with it. Shimoda had her hands up, but it was still nasty. The heels retake control after a run-in but when Shimoda attempts a move, Kyoko catches her with a DDT. Kyoko and Kong do their classic comedy leglock spot! Great stuff. They release their respective holds and Inoue ends up getting stun-gunned on the top rope from a fireman's carry position. Slingblade by Mita and then another! Mita heads to the top rope but Kyoko meets her up there and tosses her off with a release belly-to-belly! Inoue and Kong go to the floor only to be met by a springboard somersault seated senton by Mita! I love that they were held in place by LCO's henchman too. Shimoda's suicide dive isn't as pretty, but that's maybe my first criticism of this match. One of the commentators gets knocked from his seat because this match is so out of control. Kong grabs a beer can and smashes it on Shimoda's head. Meanwhile, Inoue takes out Mita elsewhere in the arena. Up on one of the balconies, Kong tries to shove Shimoda off as the crowd goes wild! Shimoda tries to choke her out with a rope and send her over instead! This shit is nuts. Mita and Shimoda take out Inoue in the ring, but Kong comes back with a fire extinguisher. Kong fills the arena with fire extinguisher chemical as the combatants continue to lay into each other with chair shots. LCO are in control, working on Kyoko, but she rallies with a double clothesline and her and Kong hit a double press slam on Shimoda and then another on Mita onto a bed of chairs in the middle of the ring! Wow. Brutal chair shot by Kong to Mita! Even more brutal one to Shimoda! Holy shit. Kong and Inoue set up a table and Kong piledrives Mita through it! Somehow there's a kickout, though, if the match ended there, it'd probably still be one of the best matches I've ever seen. Powerbomb/piledrives combo by Kong but Shimoda breaks the count! The LCO head out of the ring for a breather and we get another bit of brawling. Back in the ring, Kyoko and Kong hit a flying double clothesline on Mita and then Kyoko lays into her with even more clotheslines as she hangs on the ropes. Kyoko tries a German suplex but Mita counters it into a brief ankle lock and then tags out. I'm not sure if that was a botch or not or if Mita simply couldn't execute what they were supposed to do because she was concussed or whatever. Shimoda comes in and hits Kyoko with some two-hand strikes before tagging Mita back in. They send Kyoko into the ropes but she springboards off the middle with double back elbows. Kong hoists Mita up on her shoulders and Kyoko hits a back elbow off the top, a very nifty variation of the Doomsday Device that some tag team should totally steal.  It only gets a 2.5, though, so Kyoko tries a powerbomb only to get mist sprayed in her face! Shimoda drops her with another two-hand strike but Kyoko comes off the ropes with a clothesline soon after. Kyoko tries the back elbow off the top but gets caught in a devastating Electric Chair by Shimoda! Damn, that had to hurt. Shimoda tries a fireman's but gets clocked with a clothesline and in comes Kong. Chairshot by Mita to Kong's back! Kong misses a crossbody! Shimoda hoists her up and drops her with an Electric Chair and then Mita comes off the top with a splash for another 2.9. Shimoda goes to the top, Kong meets her up, but Mita pulls her down. Shimoda throws a chair at Kong's skull from the top rope! 1....2...kickout. Damn. Another chairshot by Shimoda soon after but, on the third one, Kong dodges it and Mita gets hit instead! Splash by Kong...but it only gets 2.9! Kong goes back to the top but one of LCO's goons starts attacking her. This allows Mita to try for a German, but Kyoko pulls her down with one of her own and Kong lands a huge back elbow from the top. Brutal. It only gets 2 so Kong tries for a back suplex but Mita counters it with a bridging back suplex of her own for 2. Kyoko nails Mita with a trash can and Kong dumps her on the back of her head with a suplex...but again it only gets 2.9! Someone slides in a chair and Kong asks for another as Kyoko's hand gets taped to the ropes! There's now a bed of chairs and Kong drops Mita into them with a brainbuster! 1...2...Shimoda breaks the count. Shimoda throws a chair at Kong's head and then another! Shimoda tries a fireman's carry but can't keep Kong up! On the third attempt, she hits the Death Valley Driver onto the bed of chairs! She places Mita on top of Kong...but Kyoko breaks the count! Crazy false finish there. Kyoko with a powerbomb to Shimoda! She grabs Mita by the hair and tries to wake up Kong. Kyoko has Mita in place for an Uranake but Kong is stumbling....she hits the Uranake! And that is it. Wow. I wouldn't call the match perfect because there was a very slight lull at one point and I could see the argument that there were almost too many false finishes, but this was about as violent and awesome as a pro-wrestling match can get and easily one of the best matches I've ever seen. (5/5)



Will Ospreay, Kyle Fletcher, and Mark Davis vs. Robbie X, Callum Newman, and Lee Hunter (11/07/2021, Revolution Pro Wrestling): Fast-paced, but not super "spotty," I was surprised how much Fletcher faded into the background a bit compared to Davis. Then again, Davis being the most physically imposing out of all six men certainly helped him standout as the rest of the participants all have fairly similar styles. Ospreay was clearly the star of the bunch and his offense got the loudest reactions, but Robbie X was very good as well. This was fine for what it was and, while it probably would've felt long on TV, its important to remember the context of an indie show is that the matches are primarily done for the fans in attendance and that an 10-minute six-man tag featuring Ospreay is simply not going to cut it when the crowd, or at least a large portion of it, was clearly there to see him perform. (3/5)



Shinobu Kandori vs. Manami Toyota (08/23/1998, AJW): This was a very different sort of match from Toyota as she was borderline heelish from the jump, locking Kandori in a sleeper when she goes in for a handshake at the bell. Toyota is clearly driven to win the 3WA Championship, throwing everything she can at Kandori, who is much more of an MMA-inspired worker with her devastating strikes and submission game. This felt like a real war and a real main event championship match, but they may have overdone it a bit with the false finishes at the end. Still, a very good, hard-hitting match worth checking out if you're into either competitor. (3.5/5)



Zack Sabre Jr. vs. Pete Dunne (08/06/2016, OTT): Over The Top Wrestling is an independent company based in Dublin, Ireland. Pete Dunne was very over with this crowd; not in the sense that they loved him, but that they clearly were loving to hate him, the entire audience flipping him the bird during his entrance. There were moments in this that grabbed my attention - the joint manipulation, Sabre Jr. dodging a strike and Dunne striking the post instead - but it didn't hold onto my attention from beginning to end the way a truly great match does. As one would expect, there is a ton of grappling in this and I daresay that Dunne, with his natural charisma, almost upstages Sabre Jr. even in that department. A good match, but not a great one. (3/5)


Yumiko Hotta vs. Shinobu Kandori (03/21/1998, LLPW): I was a little surprised to see this match had a near-10 score on Cagematch as, while it was definitely very intense, very physical, and really surprising in its brevity, it didn't strike me as a "must see" match. Then again, I went into this match cold in regards to the context or history between the competitors and just kinda watched it at face value: Kandori is an MMA-inspired badass, Hotta is an MMA-inspired badass, let's see who wins. Hotta gets some serious "color" but I didn't find it grotesque. (3/5)


Yoshinari Ogawa and Zack Sabre Jr. vs. Roderick Strong and Slex (07/20/2013, NOAH): Context would've probably helped me understand this match much better as Ogawa was a bastard to Sabre Jr. in this match. I'd never heard of Slex before and can't say I was too impressed. Him and Strong make for a good team as far as execution and offense, but they're not a particularly exciting or interesting one. I usually really enjoy Ogawa and Sabre Jr. but this match did very little for me and it felt needlessly long. (2/5)


Chigusa Nagayo vs. Manami Toyota (11/29/1998, AJW): Considering Nagayo was one of the biggest and best stars of the 1980s and Toyota was a huge star in the 90s, this felt like something of a "dream match" but never really clicked. It's pretty incredible to think that Nagayo was still wrestling (though, with increasing rarity) through the 2010s, but this match doesn't make me necessarily eager to see much of her recent work. There seems to be something of a styles clash going on and a lack of a cohesive, engaging, and purposeful layout hurts this too. Toyota gets a bunch of her signature spots in, but it feels a bit paint-by-numbers compared to her better matches. (2/5)


Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Jun Akiyama (02/27/2000, AJPW): Really enjoyed the third of this with Misawa and Akiyama both dishing out some big moves and Misawa pulling off an awesome shoulder tackle off the apron and then taking a wicked bump into the guardrail. They slow things down a bit in the middle portion but Misawa brings so much emotion to his submissions/headlocks that it never gets too dull. Around the 15-20 minutes mark, Akiyama hits a dropkicks on Misawa as he's perched on the top rope and Misawa takes another nasty fall to the outside and then eats a running knee off the apron. He follows it up by putting his knee on the back of Misawa's head and "riding him" into the guardrail, but a cameraman prevents us from seeing the actual impact. Akiyama hits a Gotch-style piledrives that looks like it could've paralyzed Misawa and then a T-Bone Suplex/Exploder for another near fall. He tries for a submission but Misawa gets to the ropes. Misawa cuts off Akiyama's momentum with a heel kick and then goes to the top for a beautiful frog splash. He tries for a Tiger Driver but has to settle for a German suplex. Akiyama gets to his feet and has a busted nose to Misawa elbows him in the face in the corner and then hits him with a ton of forearms. Misawa hits the Tiger Driver...but only gets 2! Release German Suplex by Misawa! Akiyama looks practically dead at this point and Misawa hits a second Tiger Driver...but again, Akiyama gets his shoulder up! Misawa goes for the Burning Hammer but Akiyama counters it into an Exploder! Then another! He can't make the cover, though, as he's too exhausted and Misawa ends up in the corner. Akiyama gets to his feet and hits a running knee and then another Exploder! 1...2...kickout by Misawa this time! Akiyama hits a brainbuster but only gets 2! The crowd is going absolutely bonkers at this point as Akiyama delivers some sort of fisherman/wrist-clutch suplex driver thing to get the W. Aside from a slight dip when the match kinda lost me, this was very, very good and featured a tremendous third act. Very much worth checking out. (4/5)