Kazuchika Okada vs. Roderick Strong (08/22/2015, ROH): Maybe I haven't seen enough Okada matches to fully "get" the genius because this felt more like a Roderick Strong showcase than a match where Okada shined. Strong shows off a whole fireworks display of running knees, awesome counters to the Rainmaker, and his signature backbreakers, fully in control of the first half of the bout before Okada starts cutting him off with dropkicks and whatnot. I liked the conciseness of the match and that it doesn't actively try to be an "epic," opting instead to just keep their respective feet on the pedal for 15 minutes. Solid match. (3/5)
Bryan Danielson vs. Nigel McGuinness (02/28/2008, ROH): The Danielson/McGuiness match from England blew my mind, so I was looking forward to this one quite a bit. While I don't think it measures up, it's not far off. There were two stories here - first, Danielson refusing to attack Nigel's head due to his history of concussions (a nod to the "honor" aspect of Ring of Honor) and, second, Nigel showing no honor by getting himself disqualified at one point and then, later, delivering some nasty headbutts to Danielson's previously-injured eye. The early DQ was a great way to get heat from an already lively crowd (one that was initially split between Nigel and AmDrag), but I personally tend to dislike that gimmick and, because I wasn't an avid Ring of Honor viewer, the surprise of a bunch of Ring of Honor ex-champs getting together to prevent Nigel from walking out on the match didn't have the emotional power that it probably did for others. If the match in England was Danielson working brilliantly as the pseudo-heel, this is Nigel's turn and he does a masterful job as well. The eventual pay-off to Danielson's refusal to attack Nigel's head is an amazing moment and I'll give him a ton of credit of making the audience wait for it, but I kinda wish there had been even more of it. (3.5/5)
Roddy Piper and Rick Martel vs. The Sheepherders (03/15/1980, PNW): Late 70s/early 80s wrestling from Portland is not something I'd seen much of anything from when it popped up on my YouTube feed. The production is definitely not great - this match seemed to have been uploaded from a very old VHS - but its not as bad as some of the other stuff I've watched recently (especially the early joshi stuff). Anyway, this was also the first time I've seen Piper and Martel in tag action and both super over as straight-up babyfaces while I'm much more familiar with seeing the Sheepherders working as the good guy Bushwhackers. Anyway...I like the excitement of the crowd and the announcer and there's some fun to be had watching Roddy Piper outsmart the referee to maintain control over the heels, but this dragged at times and got repetitive and I wanted to see more of Martel's agility and fire because when he was showing off what he could do, it was awesome. The finish was lackluster too as this was a relatively long match (nearly 20 minutes) and ended with Buddy Rose running in and causing a DQ. I think fans of this particular style and brand and era of wrestling would consider this good stuff, but I wasn't enthralled by any of it. (2/5)
Rick Martel vs. Jumbo Tsuruta (05/13/1984, AWA): A good, not great match, though I'm sure it was a bigger moment for those that had been following Martel's career and hard work. This was a rather straightforward championship match but featured some small details I liked - Tsuruta working on Martel's leg early on, Martel's agility and selling, the finishing sequence and how it protected Jumbo even as he dropped the AWA World Championship here. I also thought, for a match that goes over 20 minutes, it is really action-packed, especially for that era. That being said, it's not a spectacular match and neither guy gives the type of "career performance" that would make this "must see." (3/5)
Scorpio Sky vs. Ronin (01/05/2008, PWG): This was the first (and likely the last?) Ronin match I've ever seen. He's a heavyset guy in a costume resembling a Power Ranger, but he moves decently for a big man. Scorpio Sky was very young here. Not much to say about this match aside from it going maybe a bit long and not being super interesting, but they clearly were working hard. I only watched this because it is part of the PWG All Star Weekend show that I started months back and I wanted to at least try to finish it. (2/5)
Joey Ryan & Scott Lost vs. Tyler Black & Jimmy Jacobs (01/05/2008, PWG): Another one from the same PWG show as the match above. Tyler Black now wrestles as Seth Rollins and is a huge, huge star in the WWE. Here, he looks pale and much, much thinner. In terms of execution, there are some really ugly spots in this match, but they were clearly trying to "steal the show" by putting on a fireworks display and, though there are some duds, there are also some nifty sequences and great high-risk maneuvers on display. I really liked Rollins' busting out the Fosbury Flop to the floor and some of the excellent double-team maneuvers. I was less into the countless false finishes, which seemed like overkill, especially as we neared the 20-minute mark. Fun match when it wasn't hurt by a cringe-inducing botch (like Jimmy Jacobs' atrocious hurricanrana late in the match) and if you can ignore watching Joey Ryan knowing he's a sex pest. (2.5/5)
Rick Martel vs. Nick Bockwinkel (09/20/1984, AWA): Some people consider this an all-time classic, but maybe my tastes are just too pedestrian, uncouth, or zapped by modern style to appreciate this as much as I should. Whatever. This is really good and, based on what I've watched over the past few years, I've become a huge Nick Bockwinkel fan and might even consider him the most underrated wrestler of all time just because he was never a top guy or even an upper midcarder in the NWA/WCW or WWE (which has led to him almost being completely erased from history). Watching Rick Martel work as a babyface is fun and new for me as I'd really only known him for his late 80s/early 90s work in the WWE. Both guys are great sellers and bumpers and also aggressive, physical fighters. You don't get a ton of dives and crazy sequences, but this is old school wrestling that is worked around submission holds and tiring out your opponent and the "character work" is subtle and not over-the-top the way you might get from a Ric Flair match around this time or with what the WWE was doing during the Hulkamania Era. I would've liked a more definitive finish and I'm not a fan of pinfalls getting reversed because new information is brought to light. To me, a pinfall is a pinfall and there's no "instant replay" in wrestling. (3.5/5)
Terry Funk vs. Stan Hansen (08/24/1985, AJPW): These two always bring the goods, though this match is not as bloody and wild as their classic from 83'. Hansen controls most of this very physical match with Funk taking some awesome bumps to the outside over the top rope. If this is a "lesser" match, it's still better than most wrestling matches just because of how tough and "real" Hansen and Funk come across. This ends with Ted DiBiase showing up and he and Hansen trying to murder Funk with a bullrope. Dory shows up for the save, setting up a tag match that I'm kinda curious about having not really seen DiBiase in this setting/context before. Good stuff. (3/5)
Stan Hansen vs. Nick Bockwinkel (04/20/1986, AWA): Not a great match, but decent enough because both Bockwinkel and Hansen are so good. Loved Hansen's knees and elbow drop. Loved Bockwinkel being able to take him up for a bodyslam and a piledriver later on. Wasn't a huge fan of the finishing stretch, though, as some of it looked sloppy and off-the-mark and the ref bump was a weak ending to an otherwise good, physical contest. Some people really hate this match and I can understand the disappointment when you have two guys who are capable of so much more. However, I don't think Bockwinkel was eager to take the kind of mauling that Hansen was known to dish out and I don't think Hansen wanted to work a more technical, straight-up wrestling match either. Decent enough for what it is. (2.5/5)
Jackie Sato vs. Maki Ueda (02/27/1979, AJW): I can't believe there are 20 minutes shaved off of this match (according to Cagematch). Not knowing the full story going in certainly takes away from the enjoyment. The video quality is not great either. But what you do get is some of the most spirited grappling, submission wrestling, and emotional storytelling you'll likely ever see. The crowd is incredibly into this too, which makes it even harder to accurately rate because, unless you are ultra-familiar with the workers going in, the enjoyment and emotional investment will likely come across as a "third-hand" experience (as it did for me). (4/5)